MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches
The MAC Wonder Woman collection launches in MAC stores and counters on February 10th and should be online around February 8th. Today the MAC store in Soho had a special event and then opened to the public as the first MAC store in the world to sell the collection. I schlept to Manhattan in slushy snow to see if I could get the products I coveted (I only wanted the blush duos) and to see what everything else looked like.
So I first heard the store would reopen at 2 so I got there around 2 expecting the line to be wrapped around the corner. It wasn’t. There were only three other MAC fans in front of me and no one behind me for at least 30 mins. But since the crew had to put the store back together from the press event they had earlier, we waited outside like eager beavers. But then “maybe 20 mins” turned into “about 2 hours” so we went off to shop and came back.
When I came back I was expecting pandemonium. It was super calm…lol.
The whole store was decorated with Wonder Woman paraphernalia. There were bookshelves that had comics that showed the heroine’s different looks over the past seven decades. Then I zeroed in on the makeup.
I got as far as these three pics before someone at MAC politely asked me to 86 the camera…lol. He was so nice about it though. So I swatched the rest like crazy. Only the MSFs didn’t show up enough on my skin for me to capture them with my camera. I don’t have those advanced skills yet. I also didn’t swatch the pigments as I ran out of arm space and I am WAY too clumsy to be handling pigments in confined spaces. Then after I made my purchases (the two blushes), I stepped outside to try and photograph the swatches on my hands the best I could. The water droplets you see on my hands are from the fire escape above me…lol.
Click pics to enlarge/view full size:

And here’s some packaging pics (can’t swatch the Spitfire lipstick better than the in-store swatch I did above as I picked it up for the homey Lipstick Fashion Mascara)

My thoughts?
This collection as a whole is pretty blah if you already own a lot of brighter lip colors and you’re not a huge Wonder Woman fan. Much of the collection is dupable so there isn’t a lot you need. I’d say definitely check out the blush duos—those are super pretty and look great on virtually all skintones.
You can skip the MSFs if you own any of them. I saw nothing special about them, but that could be because they didn’t show up very well on my NW47 skin. If you don’t own any MSFs at all, I’d say get one (Golden Lariat if you have warm undertones or Pink Power if you have cool undertones) if you must but know that MAC will at some point this year likely bring out more in another collection. These Wonder Woman MSFs are supersized so they’re bigger than usual.
Please do yourself a favor and skip the eyeshadow quads. They have very so-so color payoff and you can find similar colors with much better pigmentation in their permanent line.
The lipglasses are okay. I’d recommend Athena’s Kiss and Wonder Woman ONLY if you don’t have similar colors. These are also supersized so they’re about twice the regular size of MAC lipglass so they’re also a little more.
If you must go for a lipstick (Russian Red is pretty but it’s permanent), go for Spitfire if you don’t already have a deep bright pink/magenta lipstick. The others you can skip and still sleep well at night.
And that’s all I have to say about that! If you got a chance to see the collection, let me know your thoughts and what’s on your wishlist.
As always, if you have a question, leave them in the comments or contact me.
Edit: Here’s some comparison swatches of Amazon Princess Blush vs MAC Band of Roses Mineralize Blush Duo. I had no clue they were so similar until The Style and Beauty Doctor reader Temi left a comment (the dark pink part of Band of Roses has slightly more burgundy to it, but if you have this blush you don’t necessarily need Amazon Princess).

















50 Comments
New blog post: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches : http://bit.ly/gzatpT
MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches : http://bit.ly/gzatpT #MAKEUPCHAT
RT @StyleNBeautyDoc: New blog post: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches : http://bit.ly/gzatpT
RT @StyleNBeautyDoc: New blog post: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches : http://bit.ly/gzatpT
New Blog Post: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches http://bit.ly/hctcCg
MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches http://bit.ly/hctcCg by @StyleNBeautyDoc
RT @StyleNBeautyDoc: New Blog Post: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches http://bit.ly/hctcCg
RT @StyleNBeautyDoc: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches : http://bit.ly/gzatpT #MAKEUPCHAT
RT @StyleNBeautyDoc: New Blog Post: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches http://bit.ly/hctcCg
RT @Coffee0410: RT @StyleNBeautyDoc: New blog post: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches : http://bit.ly/gzatpT
RT @ThisFancyFace: RT @Coffee0410: RT @StyleNBeautyDoc: New blog post: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches : http://bit.ly/gzatpT
RT @StyleNBeautyDoc: New Blog Post: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches http://bit.ly/hctcCg
Hi Danielle
What about the colored mascara?? I was planning on purchasing the green one. Did you check it out??
Hi Sandy!
I totally forgot about the mascaras likely because #1. I’ve never been impressed by a MAC mascara #2. I stopped buying mascaras that cost more than $8…lol. But I’d say you’ll purely be buying them for novelty since you can’t use it again after about 3 months.
Hope that helped!
It really does not last longer than 3 months??? thats not good considering I will be paying $15.00. I wanted to try some different on my lashes. The green looked interesting. Now you have me re thinking purchasing mascara from Mac.
Hey! You’re really not supposed to use any mascara longer than 3 mos (risk getting bacteria in the eye) and after trying so many different mascaras from dept stores and seeing how they give the same effect as some drugstore ones, I don’t buy dept store any more.
Plus MAC mascaras have never been anything to write home about to me….lol.
Hope this helps!
Thanks for the info Danielle, its does help.
You’re welcome, Sandy :)
I want the Themyscira Mascara because the one I have from Maybelline doesn’t show up (looks blue on the brush but black on my lashes). I can’t decide between getting the russian red lipstick(since it is permanent) or spitfire(I don’t look that good in pinks). I love wendy williams wonder woman cup and wish some of the packaging looked more like that but I will still buy the mascara for sure.
Hey Taylor!
Yes–Wendy Williams’ WW cup is amazing! If you like cool toned reds and want a lipstick for the WW packaging, I say go for Russian Red :)
Thanks! I find myself wearing both cool toned and warm toned reds…bc I am a lipstick junkie :-)
Hi Taylor
Have you ever tried YSL or Lancome blue mascara?? They definitely show on my black lashes. The YSL shows more of a bright blue tint on lashes. The Lancome has more of a subtle navy blue tint on my lashes, which i love. I never tried Mac’s masacara so i’m not sure how its is. But I am thinking about trying the WW collection green mascara. Test it out in Sephora.
I love Lancome mascara(but never tried the blue)! I have never tried YSL mascara but will check both of them out this weekend at Saks or Sephora. Thanks for the tip.
Thanks for the swatches Danielle! I wanted to get on board with the blush duos myself but I don’t think i need to. YESSSS! I’ll patiently wait for MAC to re-release X-Rocks in the meantime……..lol
errrrr…….metal rock msf lol
Which of the blushes would choose out of the two if you had to ?
Hey Alicia!
Hmm–that depends on which blush colors you have more of in your stash. But if I really had to choose with no other variables, I’d personally would go with Mighty Aphrodite. But I’m a sucker for blush so that was hard to choose….lol.
I don’t like any of it and my money’s staying firmly in my wallet! Thanks for the swatches x
I wanted to get Athena’s Kiss lipglass. It looks like a great lip colour for spring/summer. How do you think it will look on my NW45 skintone??
Hey Destiny!
Athena’s Kiss will look awesome on NW45 skin! I didn’t get it because I have similar colors, but it’s a really pretty cool toned pink with enough pigment that an NW45 can rock it :)
I was in front of you on the “line” and I had no idea you were the style and beauty doctor lol. I think the collection was pretty blah too. I was expecting to want a lot but I only ended up getting golden lariat msf and spitfire l/s. Both blushes were so pretty but I have similar colors and I have to stop buying so much blush lol. Besides having to wait outside while ice water dripped on our heads it was really nice to meet you!
Omg! How cool is that! We were some troopers waiting outside for that collection…lol.. Were you the birthday girl? So cool meeting you and your friend :)
You guys should come to my social network party tomorrow. It’s at 307 Hancock St in Brooklyn from 6-10 PM. Free professional profile pic for facebook or twitter :)
MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches : http://bit.ly/gzatpT #MAKEUPCHAT
RT @StyleNBeautyDoc: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches : http://bit.ly/gzatpT #MAKEUPCHAT
MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches http://bit.ly/hctcCg by @StyleNBeautyDoc
RT @StyleNBeautyDoc: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches : http://bit.ly/gzatpT #MAKEUPCHAT
MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review and Swatches on NW47 skin http://bit.ly/dQnuze #makeupchat
RT @StyleNBeautyDoc: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review and Swatches on NW47 skin http://bit.ly/dQnuze #makeupchat
RT @StyleNBeautyDoc: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review and Swatches on NW47 skin http://bit.ly/dQnuze #makeupchat
Thanks for the swatches Danielle, my list seems to be getting shorter-especially having seen your review, which i’m grateful for.
You’re welcome!
Thanks for the swatches Danielle! This really helped with my must-have and skip products!
MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review and Swatches on NW47 skin http://bit.ly/dQnuze #makeupchat
RT @StyleNBeautyDoc: MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review and Swatches on NW47 skin http://bit.ly/dQnuze #makeupchat
Hi Danielle. My internet is back up! but yes thanks for your salon suggestion. really appreciated that.
Im thinking of the blushes..the lighter side of Mighty Aphrodite..you dont think that’ll be ashy on deeper /darker tones, yours and deeper?
as for amazon princess, very temptiing but many peple have said 9ts an exact dupe of Band of Roses? what do you think?
Hey Temi!
You’re welcome! I hadn’t realized the two were so similar until you mentioned it. I updated the post with swatch comparisons.
No–the blushes are actually quite pigmented so they won’t show up ashy on my skin or deeper. I swatched them in a way so they would show up in pics. But no ash here even on the lighter side of the blushes…lol.
So glad you posted a comparison of Amazon Princess compared to Band of Roses as I own band of roses but was eyeing Amazon Princess, so I’ll pass. I’m thinking of getting Russian Red l/s as I own the lipglass and its gorgeous, and I’ve been wanting the l/s for a while so why not in the cute wonder woman packaging lol. Great review!
*Updated w Amazon Princess vs Band of Roses swatches* MAC Wonder Woman Collection Review & Swatches http://bit.ly/gZ3uOW #makeupchat #macww
MAC Band of Roses Mineralize Blush Duo is very similar to MAC Wonder Woman Amazon Princess Blush. You don't need both http://bit.ly/gZ3uOW
I own the Amazon Princess and it’s very pretty, but I see how these are essentially novelty items and many of the colors have been duplicated from other MAC collections. Since I didn’t have a bright pink blush already, it was definitely worth it, but otherwise I’d say to save your pennies lol.
One Trackback
[...] Danielle was able to snap some other shots of other items before she left. You can at least get an idea of what it would look like on a woman of color. Check it here. [...]